4 Week Power Down Proposal: What Is Your Opinion? 🤔

in steemdao •  4 months ago  (edited)

I just saw this post about Power Down period.
https://steemit.com/steem/@steemitblog/feedback-wanted-4-week-power-down

source
There is a proposal to shorten the Power Down period from 13 weeks to 4 weeks.

I am still newish to this steemit platform and I don't really know all the pros and cons about this change.
I haven't even done Power Down yet, and I am not planning to do so.
So it is not a big deal for me if it is 13 weeks or 4 weeks.

However, I always thought it is kind of strange that your fund is locked up for 13 weeks.
It is your fund, you should be able to put it in and take it out anytime you want unless it is your saving account that you have to put your money in for a certain period of time and you can't touch it for that time frame or something...

This post points out some concerns and risks about the change.
My biggest concern is the security risk.

Security Risk
An implicit feature of Steem Power is that it time locks funds.
If your account were to be compromised, it takes a week for some of your Steem Power to even be available to the attacker and 13 weeks for them to access it all.
By reducing the power down time, an attacker could have access to a larger portion of your funds after just 7 days.

もしアカウントがハックされてパワーダウンされてしまったら、今まで資金を引き出されるのに13週間かかってたところが4週間と短くなる事で、同じ期間内(7日間)により多くの資金が盗まれる可能性があるというようなことが書いてあります。

セキュリティーのリスクがあるのは分かりますが、個人的には論点がちょっと違うかなという気がします。
busyとかesteemとかモバイルとか、他のいろんなアプリを使用するためにアクティブキイを使わないといけなかったりするので、steemitの作り自体の問題のような気がします。

I understand this logic and it is a risk related to this topic but the same time, this is a huge issue by itself I think.
We kind of have to use 3rd party apps all the time and we give them access to our active key, hoping that those apps are secure and not malicious...
So this part to me is more of a steemit design issue.

If I really think of it, why do we even need to Power Up/Down in the first place...🤔

But anyway, I think everybody needs to give them feedback and vote for or against this proposal.

You can vote on this proposal from the Steemit Wallet https://steemitwallet.com/proposals.
I think this is the right one?
3j85vu.png
パワーダウンを4週間に変更する提案にはここから投票できます。

Also read these posts too.
PROPOSAL IN FAVOR
PROPOSAL AGAINST

Authors get paid when people like you upvote their post.
If you enjoyed what you read here, create your account today and start earning FREE STEEM!
Sort Order:  

Very good, we upvoted and resteemed to thousand followers.. Thank you to approve us as your witness and curator.

You have received 5x upvotes from the members of @steemexplorers from your free link submission in our discord server. Steemexplorers is an initiative bringing information on various Steemit services and communities in a central discord to save you time and help you grow. It's free, it's easy, and it's here to help you in so many ways. Come by our discord to learn more! Link to Discord: https://discord.gg/6QrMCFq. Our team also offers an additional upvoting service called @givememonsters where you can presently trade in 1 to 10 DEC from the Steem Monsters game for up to $0.03 upvotes on ANY steemit posts. The vote purchasing value here is some of the best returns on your investments that you can find anywhere so come by and visit this service today!

  ·  4 months ago 

Well, it's good for people that want to leave steemit but bad via high steem in circulation

Yay!
Your post has been boosted with ESTM. Keep up the good work!
Dear reader, Install Android, iOS Mobile app or Windows, Mac, Linux Surfer app!
Learn more: https://esteem.app
Join our discord: https://discord.me/esteem

  ·  4 months ago 

私はbusyにポスティングキーでログインしていますよ。

  ·  4 months ago 

busyはいいかもですね。。。
どのアプリはどのキーが必要とか、キーが何個もあったり使い分けが必要なUXは個人的に良くない気がするんですよね。
それももしかしたらデザインとかUIで改善出来るかもしれないですが。

  ·  4 months ago 

紛らわしいですね。以前より少しずつ改善されてきています。多くの方が話題にすることで、さらに改善していくのではと思います。

  ·  4 months ago 

そうなんですね。
このパワーダウンもどう改善されていくのか興味深いですね。

  ·  4 months ago 

ちょっと訂正があります。
通常のログインはポスティングキーでログインできるのですが、busyへの一番最初のログインの時だけはアクティブキーが必要のようです。済みませんでした^^;

  ·  4 months ago 

そんなのヒドイ😭
でも凄いですねちゃんと調べられて。素晴らしいです。