Do you think there's merit on edited photos?

in #photography2 years ago

You see, my brother's first question after I show him a photo is:

"But is this edited or was it like this for real?"

And I've been giving some thought to this lately, because most of the time you can actually capture the scene in its vibrant (or dull) colours and the whole splendour of it, however, on the post-production stage you can really bring out details and even colours that were not easy to see or appreciate in the original photo.

So, today I decided to go ahead and upload the last Austrian sunset I shot, without editing it.

Please, feel free to let me know in the comments what are your thoughts about original versus edited photos.


Posted using Partiko Android


If you take a shot and use the JPEG straight out of camera. It’s also edited... The camera firmware would have done some edit to make color boost. Especially true with point and shoot cameras.

Even when cameras were still using films, the paper photos that came out are also edited. The edit process was done in the dark room with over/under exposure etc...

Is there merit on edited photos? I think there is. Maybe a photographer first needs to figure what is his/her purpose. But editing is part of the process. You either limit yourself to rendering an image that is as close to what the real thing is or you then become creative and your are generating a new image.

I think people think it’s cheating because they think they are being duped. The photographer might have made it sounds like as if the photo is real (it partly is) but then the viewer realise that the real thing does not look as good. So maybe it’s a task for the photographers to display a disclaimer to let their viewer know what was involved in the editing process? Was the edit intended to just adjust exposures and WB to match reality or was it more involved to create something new?

Posted using Partiko iOS

Thanks a lot for your insight, @quochuy.

So maybe it’s a task for the photographers to display a disclaimer to let their viewer know what was involved in the editing process?

Well I think it also depends. Maybe sometimes it's good let the viewer wonder what is real and what is not.

Perhaps when the photo looks surreal and very small edition has been made, then it's interesting to leave such disclaimer :)

Posted using Partiko Android

Thank you so much for being an awesome Partiko user! We have just given you a free upvote!

The more Partiko Points you have, the more likely you will get a free upvote from us! You can earn 30 Partiko Points for each post made using Partiko, and you can make 10 Points per comment.

One easy way to earn Partiko Point fast is to look at posts under the #introduceyourself tag and welcome new Steem users by commenting under their posts using Partiko!

If you have questions, don't feel hesitant to reach out to us by sending us a Partiko Message, or leaving a comment under our post!