500 Words a Day — Saying Goodbye to Yahoo — 22.7.2020

in 500 Words a day3 months ago (edited)

For a long time, I’ve had a guilty pleasure. Or a sinkhole of wasted time, depending on point of view.

I’ve been a denizen of the Yahoo comments section.

Sure, nowadays Yahoo is old school. But I’m not exactly young. And I’ve used Yahoo since before it had the Yahoo.com URL, way back in 1994 when Jerry Yang and David Filo were hosting it on their university’s servers and it was nothing more than a directory of other websites. Not even a search function.

And thanks to the power of inertia, I kept using the service. Had an email account there almost as soon as they started offering them. Their spam filter really sucked, and I ditched the mail service years ago.

But when they started being a news aggregator, as a news junkie I was hooked. (I was still a regular newspaper reader at the time.) At some point, I realized that you could leave comments. Count me in.

They got huge in the Dotcom Bubble, crashed and burned along with a lot of tech companies, had disastrous data breaches, got acquired (twice). All along, I was posting comments from one of my not-my-real-name throwaway accounts.

I have no idea how many people post there, but it’s a lot. Enough that, with very few exceptions, you usually have no clue about the account that you’re responding to or even whether you’ve had interactions with them before. Some interesting conversations along the way of course but also a huge number of trolls. I used to put them on Ignore but don’t know if that option’s even been available recently. There were so many trolls that if you ignored one, a dozen new ones were around.

In retrospect, I really had no good reason to stay there, let alone post comments. RSA feeds and much better news aggregators came along. I utilized them but continued to comment. On all kinds of topics. Investing, scientific discoveries, sports here and there even if I’m not a fanatic fan like some are, human interest stories, technology, you name it. And a bunch of current events and politics. Not surprisingly a lot of conflict there. Some topics I didn’t touch with a ten-foot pole. Others I’d dive right in.

Initially, Yahoo moderators treaded carefully. Eventually they started deleting comments, sometimes quite innocuous ones. They banned the use of certain words which would be auto-replaced by nonsense characters. Very inconsistently. Nazi and Klan banned, fascist and Communist okay. A few days ago, any word containing ass changed to things like !$!$!$igned, cl!$!$!$ic or B!$!$!$omatic.

Today, all comments vanished. In their place,

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting. In the meantime, we welcome your feedback to help us enhance the experience.

Call it censorship or call it a sound business decision. It’s my excuse to quit cold turkey and never go back.


I’m heading up north tomorrow for four days, three nights at a rented cabin. No idea if I’ll have cell phone coverage, so I may or may not be on Hive over the next few days.


Well, it is a good decision to leave Yahoo!, not only because of their lack of reliability (inaccurate search results), usability (difficult to just do anything), security (they have more than one data breach), but also because they are in the United States, whose federal government has very extensive surveillance of not only its citizens, but also in the entire world. It does not matter if Yahoo! is not a Big Tech company (they are very unlikely to be one due to their bad business decisions) - being based in the United States makes them legally required to provide their users' data (from U.S. residents or not) to the government without a warrant.

Enjoy the cabin

Congratulations @preparedwombat! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You distributed more than 34000 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 35000 upvotes.

You can view your badges on your board And compare to others on the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Enjoy your time at the cabin!! It is actually nice to take a break from all electronic media at times!!

Sure, nowadays Yahoo is old school. But I’m not exactly young. And I’ve used Yahoo since before it had the Yahoo.com URL, way back in 1994 when Jerry Yang and David Filo were hosting it on their university’s servers and it was nothing more than a directory of other websites. Not even a search function.

OMG, that's so retro. 😂
I do remember yahoo being a thing back when I started on the internet but only ever used it for a search engine. That was obviously before google came along and cleaned them out.

I have come across some of their finance articles but didn't even know about some of the other options that they offered. They do have a loyal userbase but if they have gone that far into censorship I can see it dropping fairly fast.

I understand moderation but so many sites have taken it too far at this stage. Unless people can comment and debate a topic then there is not much point in posting anything since it will all be from a single narrative in content and comments.

Wow, you were there in the beginning. I remember how frustrating the internet used to be during the days of dial-up. It still seemed like magic though. Enjoy your time up North!

Oh, I was around before that. 😅

The first “computer” I ever used was actually a dumb terminal and I’d pick up a landline phone, dial a “timeshare mainframe” and physically inset the receiver into a 300-baud modem so that I could write a program in BASIC to save to a paper tape device.

Whoa, you were a pioneer! Are we talking late-70's/mid-80's? I bet that was so exciting back then to be about to do that. I remember my first computer, it was a Tandy from Radio Shack. My iPhone probably has 100x the processing power. I would spend hours learning how to write programs to make a pixelated cartoon figure walk across the screen.

The dumb terminal with the 300-baud modem was 1973. A lifetime ago; I’m now 64.

the comments were the most fun part about that aggregator. I left for the most part as well but to be fair, i am wasting a lot less time looking at multiple comments made by people who don't know how to spell throw insults an each other.