The Fall of Gil-Galad

avatar

Gil-galad was an Elven-king.
Of him the harpers sadly sing;
the last whose realm was fair and free
between the Mountains and the Sea.

His sword was long, his lance was keen.
His shining helm afar was seen;
the countless stars of heaven's field
were mirrored in his silver shield.

But long ago he rode away,
and where he dwelleth none can say;
for into darkness fell his star
in Mordor where the shadows are.

This is chanted by Sam Gamgee, it's a small portion of a longer poem called The Fall of Gil-Galad, originally written in an ancient tongue and translated by Bilbo.

If you want to hear an idea of what it might sound like if chanted, here is a pretty good version:


If you caught my last post, you saw mention that I've been reading my boy The Fellowship of the Ring the past few nights. He's understanding it better than I had thought he would. I have to stop every now and again and explain a word (for instance, he stopped me as I was reading the poem above to ask what "dwelleth" means) but he is picking up a lot from context and is remembering most of what happened in previous nights. All in all, the reading goes well. Our last reading ended shortly after the poem above.

externalcontent.duckduckgo.jpg

This poem is an example of what I love about Tolkien. He throws us into a world and gives us numerous hints and allusions to the history of this world, often without any explanation at all.

As Aragon speaks of Weathertop and tells of its name of old, Amon Sûl, and of how the Men of the West built it to defend against the evil that came out of Angmar. Later, as Aragon chants the tale of Beren and Lúthien. Earlier, in the house of Tom Bombadil when he made mention of remembering before the seas were bent. We learn nothing more of these things in this book. The rest of Lord of the Rings gives hints, but we don't really learn any of the history of the world until The Silmarillion.

These hints of the larger history of the land enchanted me when I was a boy reading the story for the first time. They give a sense of wonder and awe. I hope my son is feeling something of the same.

At this point in my life I have read The Silmarillion, The Lost Tales, most of Christopher Tolkien's History of Middle Earth books, as well as the three newer books he published before his death that retold key stories from the Silmarillion, so I know most of the history of Middle Earth and know exactly what each one of these allusions in Fellowship of the Ring is referring to. But y'know, it was almost better before I knew the background.

Screen Shot 20210110 at 20.14.02.png


Anyway, yeah, so that's where we are now. We'll see how my boy reacts to the coming scuffle on Weathertop, which we should cover tomorrow.



0
0
0.000
5 comments
avatar
(Edited)

Hi David

What a great experience to share with your son.

I love that Youtube reading you shared and that particular song from LOR always sent a shiver up my spine when I used to listen to the audio book.

Also the song Samwise sings in the Tower of Cirith Ungol while searching for Frodo holds that same sadness mingled with the ethereal and almost a nostalgia that Tolkien expresses so well in his poems/songs. Although it doesn't hold so much history as the fall of gil galad.

In western lands beneath the Sun
the flowers may rise in Spring,
the trees may bud, the waters run,
the merry finches sing.
Or there maybe 'tis cloudless night
and swaying beeches bear
the Elven-stars as jewels white
amid their branching hair.
Though here at journey's end I lie
in darkness buried deep,
beyond all towers strong and high,
beyond all mountains steep,
above all shadows rides the Sun
and Stars for ever dwell:
I will not say the Day is done,
nor bid the Stars farewell.

It sounds like we had a similar experience in the profound effect that Tolkien's writing had growing up. I also read LOR at a young age, more than once. And it would always whisk me away in my mind more so than any other book series has to be honest. It was the Hobbit, and soon after LOR, that started my lifelong love of reading fantasy, and the first fiction I ever wrote (at the age of twelve) was a story set in middle earth just after the departure of Gandalf and Frodo to the undying lands. It featured Sam, Peregrine and Merry visiting Tom Bombadil and him fading to merge with the trees, water and earth with the advent of the age of man. I wish I could find it to be honest... it got me an A in English 😂

I since read all the histories of Tolkiens setting and it just goes to show how important 'world building' is in fantasy. The stories of the Valar and Maiar and that of Numenor add so much understanding to the magic and mythology behind the wizards and 'The men of the west'. That richness of history in lord of the rings is like a light that shines through a veil, where the light it all that subcreation and the veil our imagination. It is like a reflection shimmering through the ripples on a lake.

Anyway, I'm getting all esoteric. I salute you for passing the wonder of middle earth on to a new generation through the book rather than the movies. There is so much more to the books 👍

I'm glad to see you are alive and well my friend. And wish you all the best, and health for 2021 as we all (hopefully) emerge from this pandemic and see the light at the end of the tunnel.

0
0
0.000
avatar

@raj808 - Oh I completely agree about the books. Introducing my son to the books before the movies was utmost on my mind. I want him to get a feeling for the world, get a hint of what things look like in his own mind, before he sees the films. I don't think much of The Hobbit films at all and won't be showing them, but I already told him that after we finish the entire Lord of the Rings books we can watch the movies.

I did the same with the Oz books. After we read the entire series, I let him watch the 1939 (?) film. He loved it, but he kept pointing out things that were "wrong" (i.e., different from the books).

Maybe I'll mention this in another post, but last night when we read we covered Strider's singing of the song of Beren and Lúthien, giving my son his first mention of the Silmarils. At first he asked "Oh, are they like the ring?" then when the song mentions they are jewels, he exclaimed "Oh! Like the Arkenstone!"

I'm sure you are aware, as I am, of the many debates among Tolkien fans about whether or not the Arkenstone was one of the Silmarils (personally I think it's not, but given the direction the professor's constant revisions were going, I think it may have ended up as one of them—or at least one of the lessor gems that Feanor made). So I loved hearing that immediate guess. It shows me he is listening well and really getting into the story. I just told him "Something like that, yeah."

That's If you ever find that story you wrote as a kid, you should post it here. I'd love to see what you came up with. Whilst I never wrote any LotR fanfic, when Chrono Trigger was released, I think I was around middle school age, and I wrote a very LotR-esque fanfic, adding in a Morgoth-type figure.

Thanks for reading my rambling post and hanks for the great comment! At the moment I am planning on sticking around here, so... we'll see how that goes 😃 Maybe if I do, we can finally do that poetry/haiku collaboration we had planned before.

0
0
0.000
avatar

I don't think much of The Hobbit films at all and won't be showing them, but I already told him that after we finish the entire Lord of the Rings books we can watch the movies.

Agree completely. The hobbit movies sucked big time. LOTR movies were quite well done and I was certainly impressed by them when they first came out.

I'm sure you are aware, as I am, of the many debates among Tolkien fans about whether or not the Arkenstone was one of the Silmarils (personally I think it's not, but given the direction the professor's constant revisions were going, I think it may have ended up as one of them—or at least one of the lessor gems that Feanor made).

I have heard of this, but I was always under the impression that it was a gift from the elves to Thror his great grandfather. And I'm sure it says in the hobbit that it held starlight forever mirrored in the facets of the jewel, or some such. It has been a long time since I read it. But I definitely didn't think it was a Silmaril, mainly because of the story of Eärendil baring the Silmaril on his brow across the heavens in a boat fashioned by the Valar as a star. It was my understanding that the light of the Arkenstone was light captured from the star of Eärendil. I can't remember where I read that though. Lol, I'm over 40 now and my big phase of obsession with middle earth history was between the age of 13 -17 🤣

At the moment I am planning on sticking around here, so... we'll see how that goes 😃 Maybe if I do, we can finally do that poetry/haiku collaboration we had planned before.

Sounds like a plan. Speak again soon m8

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

@raj808 - No, it was found in the Lonely Mountain by an ancestor of Thorin. I don't remember the exact lines in the Hobbit, but it is something about how it produces it's own light, which is very similar to the description of the Silmarils. Also the effect the Arkenstone has on everyone who sees it is again similar to the effect of the Silmarils. The theory is that the it is the Silmaril that was thrown into the fires of the earth, having worked up through induction and movement of the tectonic plates over the many years into a location under the mountain where the dwarves found it.

With the current texts I don't agree with the theory. But Tolkien was planning another revision of the Hobbit at one point to further tie it to the world of Middle-Earth, so I have no doubt the Arkenstone would have eventually become a Silmaril. The both share the same word root, evidently, as Tokien gave the Old English of Silmaril as Eorclanstanas.

Anyway, just one of those fun things Tolkien fans love to debate about.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Hi @dbooster

Yes, you are absolutely right about everything you're saying. It just goes to show how long it is since I've read the hobbit... and also how badly my chromic illness effects my memory and cognitive abilities.

For some reason my mind was combining/confusing facts about the phial of Galadriel with the legend of the Silmaril and the Arkenstone.

Thinking about it now I can completely see why fans might think The Arkenstone was a lost Silmaril, and it isn't beyond the realms of possibility that this is what Tolkien meant in giving the Arkenstone that magical/hypnotic power.

Ha ha, it has been nice chatting Tolkien law with you. Back in university, before I got ill with this gut condition, I might have been a worthy debate opponent as my knowledge was much more encyclopedic.

Take care m8.

0
0
0.000