An elaborated study in writing a choral prelude

Two days ago I published a choral prelude by Friedrich Wilhelm Marpurg and called the accompanying post "A study in writing a choral prelude" (see here). My descrption of the proces was perhaps a bit dense.

You start with a four part harmonisation of a choral melody. Than you leave the notes for the bass voice and the soprano voice the same. And you take the notes for the alto and tenor voice to create a lince that moves in eigth notes between bass and soprano.

So I thought I'd elaborate a bit about the procedure. And the proof of the pudding is of course in the eating, so let's see whether the procedure really works.

green-chameleon-s9CC2SKySJM-unsplash.jpg

Marpurg starts with a harmonisation of the choral melody. With this I mean that he adds the appropriate chords to the melody. This is an art in itself, that I wont go into now. Classicaly, harmonisation is written in four parts, meaning that each chor consists of four notes. Singing is the basis of al music, and four part harmony is derived from choir singing. One note for each of the four voices of a choir: soprano, alto, tenor and bass.

image.png

The choral melody is in the upper voice, the soprano voice. The bass voice provides the fundament of the harmony. The note that the bass sings determines the chord. Alto and tenor voice just fill in the harmony. Now we strip out the alto and tenor voice.

image.png

And the deleted notes will form the building material of the voice we want to create anew. A voice that moves in eigth notes to provide some motoric drive. The first half bar is an e major chord. And the characteristic note in a major chord is of course the major third. So we need something with the noes e, g sharp and b.

image.png

The next chord is an a minor chord, with the minor third (the note c) in the bass. Usually, in a four part harmonisation, the third of the chord is written only once. To make up a four note chord from a major triad, one of the three notes has to be doubled. And usually that's either the base note of the fifthe. An a minor chord consists of the notes a - c - e. The "c" is already in the bass voice, the "a" is the melody note, so that leaves the "e" and possibly the "a" for the voice we are writing. But in this case the "a" can not be used, because in the previous bar tha last note of both the soprano voice and the extra voice we are writing is an "e". And they cannot both move to "a", as that would create a paralel octave, and writing paralel octaves is not recommended (in classical harmony theory: it is "forbidden"...). So that leaves the "e" as the only possibility. Obviously Marpurg thought 'okay "e" it is' and he ties the "e" over from the previous bar and then repeats the chord notes "e" and "a".

image.png

The next chord is an e major chord, with again the major third in the bass voice. That leaves the "e" and the "b" for the middle voice we are writing. Now Marpurg does something a bit unexpected. He throws in a notes that does not belong to the chord. The middle voice stays around the "e" and to maintain the motion of eigth notes, Marpurg places a d sharp in between as a kind of auxiliary note.

image.png

And so marpurg goes on. The next chord is an a minor chord with the lowest note, the "a" is the bass and the minor third in the choral melody. And now Marpurg does double the minor third briefly. There are reasons why in this case a doubling of the minor third is acceptable (having a lot to do with the fact that it is a minor third), but I won't go into them. The chord after that is a d major chord, with the major third in the bass. Marpurg can't double that in the middle voice. So he does the same as he did in the previous bar: he throws in an auxiliary note, in the case a g sharp. And this nicely illustrates the two opposing forces that make music so interesting. Be surprising ánd be consistent. Create something new and create something recognizable. Be creative and adhere to rules. Create the unexpected ánd create form.

image.png

The initial plan was to now use this procedure to create something of my own. But this post is already long enough as it is. So I'll leave that for a new post.

clark-young-QdRnZlzYJPA-unsplash.jpg



0
0
0.000
11 comments
avatar

It was a long time ago when I had these works in harmony and counterpoint. I liked it, but I forgot most of the rules and all. Now my son has harmonization, it's not easy to remember and help him, so I leave him on his luck haha. 😅

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

Jajaja Después de leer esto no pude evitar contestar, es muy gracioso. Te comparto los siguiente enlaces que pueden ayudar en la suerte de tu hijo jejeje... lo dejaré activo por unos días. Contiene dos libros en español bastante resumidos y pedagógicos escritos por una gran maestra de nuestro país, Violeta Lárez. Saludos!
https://www.dropbox.com/s/myswddhbky7v736/armonia1.pdf?dl=0
https://www.dropbox.com/s/yp4vlbtijhctmt1/armonia2.pdf?dl=0

0
0
0.000
avatar

Oh, llegando tarde por aquí 😂

pero, gracias de todas formas :))

ellos lo tienen explicado en el conservatorio y tiene ejercicios para hacer, pero es vago 😆

le queda menos de un mes y ya terminan el curso, creo que el año que viene ya no tiene armonía, aunque sé que tendrá 11 asignaturas en el conservatiorio , aparte de todas las clases en el instituto. Será un poco duro

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

Hola!

pero, gracias de todas formas :))

Lo dejaré nuevamente por acá :)
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/0oj5x2ztt3r8jx5fr609d/h?dl=0&rlkey=3upezm8x13nk00q5m6qc1637z

...pero es vago 😆

Si mi madre publicara eso, la demandaría jajajaja

le queda menos de un mes y ya terminan el curso...

11 asignaturas!:o Le espera mucho estudio! Éxito!

0
0
0.000
avatar

Gracias, lo he descargado ahora 👌

Si mi madre publicara eso, la demandaría jajajaja

😂😂

Menos mal, él no tiene cuenta en hive, no lo va a leer :D

Bueno, la verdad es que tienen muchas cosas, y también es la edad, el año que viene sí que le espera mucho porque son los dos últimos años - el bachillerato. Luego ya veremos, si se decide a seguier en consertavorio grado superior o no, o elige otra carrera.

Gracias de nuevo 👋

0
0
0.000
avatar

I'm a little hazy on the fine details as well. Writing posts like this helps to bring it back a bit 😀

0
0
0.000
avatar

Writing posts like this helps to bring it back a bit 😀

That's a great way to refresh our memory and skills 😇🎶🎶

0
0
0.000
avatar

I'm a little hazy on the fine details as well. Writing posts like this helps to bring it back a bit

I think the content you have published is great and useful! I don't even remember the gross details (hahaha); I have forgotten many things. Your publication prompted me to take a look at some harmony books to refresh my memory. Thanks for sharing. :)

0
0
0.000
avatar

I had already seen the post that precedes this one, I think it's great that you developed the topic in this way. Greetings!

0
0
0.000
avatar

Next step is to aply it to something new. Hopefully later this week I have time for that.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Congratulations @primalamusica! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s):

You have been a buzzy bee and published a post every day of the week.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Check out the last post from @hivebuzz:

We have finished upgrading our website
Our Hive Power Delegations to the April Power Up Month Winners
0
0
0.000